Hilarie Burton has left her mark on both the big and small screens, enthralling viewers with her versatility, charisma, and unquestionable talent. Most well-known for her breakthrough role as Peyton Sawyer in One Tree Hill, she has captivated audiences in a range of roles, from crime dramas like White Collar to heartfelt holiday films such as The Christmas Wish. Whether she’s tackling intense storylines in Grey’s Anatomy or spreading Christmas cheer in festive classics, Burton’s performances leave a lasting impression.
Let’s take a look at some of her most memorable films and television shows that have defined her career.
1. One Tree Hill (2003-2009)
IMDb RATING. 7.8/10
Hilarie Burton became famous for her role as Peyton Sawyer, a musically passionate and artistic high schooler who navigated love, loss, and personal struggles in the small town of Tree Hill. Over time, she evolved from a troubled teen into a strong, independent woman pursuing her dreams in the music industry.
The show followed half-brothers Lucas and Nathan Scott, who were rivals both on and off the basketball court. Alongside their friends, including Peyton, Brooke, and Haley, they faced challenges, love triangles, and unexpected twists that kept audiences hooked for years.
One Tree Hill wasn’t just another teen drama—it was a heartfelt series that tackled real-life issues like addiction, loss, and family struggles while celebrating the power of friendship and love.
The show developed a devoted fanbase that continues to celebrate it today. While some critics labeled it a typical teen drama, fans connected deeply with the characters and storylines. Hilarie Burton’s portrayal of Peyton was particularly praised for its emotional depth and authenticity.
Did you know Hilarie Burton was an MTV VJ before landing the role of Peyton? Her real-life passion for music made her the perfect choice for the role!
Where to Watch
One Tree Hill is available on Hulu, Max, and Amazon Prime Video.
2. White Collar (2010-2013)
IMDb RATING. 7.6/10
Burton played Sara Ellis, a sharp-witted insurance investigator with a complicated relationship with the show’s charming con artist, Neal Caffrey (Matt Bomer). Initially determined to catch him, she later became his love interest, adding intrigue and romance to the show.
If you enjoy crime dramas with a mix of action, wit, and romance, White Collar is a must-see. The chemistry between Neal and Sara added an extra layer of excitement.
The show was praised for its stylish storytelling and engaging characters. Many fans still consider Neal and Sara’s romance one of TV’s most memorable relationships.
Fun Fact: Hilarie Burton and Matt Bomer had such great on-screen chemistry that fans hoped they were a real-life couple (they’re just good friends!).
Where to Watch
White Collar is available on Hulu, Freevee, and Apple TV.
3. Grey’s Anatomy (2013)
IMDb RATING. 7.2/10
Burton guest-starred as Dr. Lauren Boswell, a confident craniofacial surgeon. Her character, featured in Season 9, brought both medical expertise and drama, particularly through a flirtatious relationship with Arizona Robbins.
If you love medical dramas filled with heartbreak, romance, and shocking twists, Grey’s Anatomy delivers. Burton’s role added tension and excitement to an already dramatic season.
Did you know that Hilarie Burton’s real-life husband, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, also appeared on Grey’s Anatomy as Denny Duquette, one of the show’s most beloved characters?
Where to Watch
Grey’s Anatomy is available on Netflix, Hulu, and ABC’s official website.
4. Lethal Weapon (2016-2017)
IMDb RATING. 7.8/10
Burton played Karen Palmer, a tough DEA agent with a complicated relationship with Martin Riggs. Her character was known for her quick wit and ability to handle high-risk situations.
Burton was initially cast for a single episode, but her performance was so well-received that producers brought her back for more!
Where to Watch
Lethal Weapon is available on Hulu, Prime Video, and Apple TV.
5. The Secret Life of Bees (2008)
IMDb RATING. 7.2/10
Burton played Deborah Owens, the deceased mother of the main character, Lily Owens (Dakota Fanning). Though her character had passed before the events of the film, her presence was deeply felt through flashbacks and Lily’s emotional journey.
Where to Watch
The Secret Life of Bees is available on Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, and Google Play Movies.
6. Naughty or Nice (2012)
IMDb RATING. 6.5/10
Overview
Burton starred as Krissy Kringle, a woman struggling with work and relationships during the holidays. After receiving Santa’s “Naughty or Nice” list, she initially enjoys exposing people’s secrets but soon learns a valuable lesson about kindness and forgiveness.
Why It’s a Must-Watch
If you love heartwarming Christmas films with a touch of magic, this movie is a delightful choice!
Where to Watch
Naughty or Nice is available on Amazon Prime Video, Hallmark Movies Now, and Apple TV.
7. The Christmas Contract (2018)
IMDb RATING. 6.8/10
Burton played Jolie Guidry, a woman who strikes a deal with her best friend’s brother to pose as her boyfriend for the holidays.
This film features a mini-reunion of One Tree Hill cast members!
The Christmas Contract is available on Lifetime, Amazon Prime Video, and Apple TV.
8. A Christmas Wish (2019)
IMDb RATING. 6.2/10
Burton starred as Faith, a woman who makes a heartfelt Christmas wish and finds love and happiness in unexpected ways.
If you love warm, feel-good holiday films, this is a perfect choice!
A Christmas Wish is available on Amazon Prime Video and Hallmark Movies Now.
9. Forever (2014)
IMDb RATING. 8.2/10
Hilarie Burton was Iona Payne, the fascinating and mysterious dominatrix. She engaged in a lengthy dialogue with the show’s main character Henry Morgan. Henry Morgan. The role she played was small, but incredibly effective in helping Henry think about his past and struggles to attain immortality. Iona was smart and confident. She also was unique in her method of looking at the world which made Iona one of the most intriguing guest characters.
The television series Forever was based on Dr. Henry Morgan, a medical examiner in New York City with a secret: he’s immortal. Every time he passes away and re-emerges to life, only to wake up in the water, totally free of any harm. In addition to solving cases, he tries to unravel the truth behind his immortality as well as his previous life. The show was a mix of drama, crime, and even a touch of fantasy, creating an exciting and unique to watch.
If you like detective stories which have supernatural elements, Forever is an excellent option! The show was a fascinating plot and the protagonist’s struggle with his ever-changing life was a great way to make it more intriguing. Hilarie Burton’s appearance on the show gave the story more depth which made her appearance an absolute must-watch.
Forever was a cult show with a loyal audience who enjoyed its blend of supernatural and crime-solving. Although reviewers gave it mixed marks however, a lot of viewers were disappointed that the show was cut after only one season. Hilarie Burton’s acting was noted as at the same time intriguing and daring.
Although the show was cancelled the fans were determined to make it happen, even launching online petitions!
Where to Watch
You can watch Forever Forever on CW Seed Apple TV, and Amazon Prime Video. If you are a fan of crime shows with a twist this is a show you should check out!
10. Bloodworth (2010)
IMDb RATING. 6.1/10
Hilarie Burton was Hazel who is an affectionate and loving woman who is warm and welcoming in the character of protagonist, a young, Fleming Bloodworth. Hazel is among the few positives in a emotionally dark story and Hilarie’s character adds warmth and depth to the story.
The film follows E. F. Bloodworth (played by Kris Kristofferson), a country singer who left his family years long ago. When he comes home after 40 years, he is confronted by his sons resentful and his grandchild, Fleming, caught between the struggles of his family as well as his own desires. The film is a deeply emotional journey through forgiveness, regret and the lasting consequences of relationships that have been broken.
Bloodworth Bloodworth an intense drama that is filled with intense emotions and stunning performances. If you like films which explore the deep conflicts of families as well as personal struggle, then this film is one to watch. The film also has an impressive cast, which includes Val Kilmer, Hilary Duff Hilary Duff, and Frances Conroy. Additionally, the gorgeous Southern setting and the country music soundtrack enhance the mood and feel of the film.
Audience and Critics’ Response
Although Bloodworth did not receive much attention at the box-office however, it was highly praised for its powerful performances and emotional story telling. It was praised by critics as an empathetic, slow drama, and viewers appreciated its profound themes of loss and love. Hilarie Burton’s character, while tiny was a standout in the movie as being one of its most warm and most touching characters.
Did you know that Bloodworth was inspired by the classic novel Provinces of Night by William Gay? The novel has a huge fan base and the film stays true to its dark Southern gothic vibe.
Where to Watch
You can watch Bloodworth through Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, and Vudu. If you love dramatic dramas that are emotional and have great storytelling, this should definitely be added to your list of movies to watch!
Final Thoughts
Hilarie Burton’s career is a testament to her talent and versatility. Whether she’s playing a strong-willed investigator, a troubled artist, or a woman finding love during Christmas, she brings authenticity and charm to every role. Whether you love crime dramas, emotional dramas, or holiday films, there’s a Hilarie Burton performance for everyone!
