Whether you first fell in love with her as the sharp and ambitious Amy Santiago on Brooklyn Nine-Nine or discovered her comedic chops elsewhere, Melissa Fumero has become a standout talent on the small screen. With a career that spans everything from animated reboots to heartfelt family comedies, Fumero continues to bring charm, wit, and heart to every role she takes on. In this list, we’re counting down the top 15 TV shows that showcase her versatility and star power — from cult favorites to hidden gems you might’ve missed.
1. Brooklyn Nine-Nine
IMdb Rating: 8.4/10
Melissa Fumero played Detective Amy Santiago in Brooklyn Nine-Nine . She’s sharp, always on top of things, and loves her job. You can count on her to be early, organized, and ready with a plan. She also has a soft side — especially when it comes to her relationship with Jake Peralta.
Amy is the kind of person who wants to do well and make people proud. She’s not just serious though — she’s funny too. Watching her grow through the show is a joy. Her bond with Jake is sweet and real, full of laughs and heart.
The story happens at a police station in New York City. It’s not your average precinct. The detectives are all different, each with their own quirks. They solve crimes, mess around, and build friendships that feel like family. The show knows how to mix serious moments with silly ones.
You’ll find yourself laughing hard one minute, then maybe wiping a tear the next. There are wild Halloween episodes where they play games for a trophy. There are also deep episodes about life, work, and what it means to be fair and kind.
Brooklyn Nine-Nine is more than comedy — it’s about people working together, sticking up for each other, and growing. It ran for eight seasons and got lots of love from viewers and critics alike. It even took home a Golden Globe. The show also made space for different voices and stories, which matters.
Here’s a little secret: Melissa was expecting during the show. They handled it with clever camera angles and big folders — smart move.
If you haven’t seen it yet, now’s the time. You can watch on Peacock, Hulu, or Netflix depending on where you live. Grab a snack, get comfy, and meet the crew at the Nine-Nine. You won’t regret it.
2. Grosse Pointe Garden Society
IMdb Rating: 8.2/10
Melissa Fumero steps into something new with Grosse Pointe Garden Society . This time, she’s Nadia — a woman who joins a garden club in a quiet, fancy town. But don’t let the flowers fool you. What looks like a group of polite ladies turns into a tangled mess of secrets, lies, and drama hiding behind rose bushes and perfectly trimmed hedges.
It’s part funny, part mysterious — like a puzzle wrapped in perfume and iced tea. You’ll laugh at the quirky neighbors, then lean in close when things get strange. Think Desperate Housewives meets Only Murders in the Building , but swap stilettos for gardening boots.
Nadia is smart, cool under pressure, and not one to back down. She’s got layers — more than just dirt on a shovel. Watching Melissa play this kind of role is fresh. You know her from being sharp and organized in Brooklyn Nine-Nine , but here, she’s got edge. It’s fun seeing her stretch in a new direction.
The show has style. The houses are big. The clothes are crisp. And the storylines? Totally wild. Critics and fans are talking about it — they like how it mixes humor with mystery without making it feel forced. It’s different. And sometimes, that’s exactly what you want on TV.
Here’s a little twist: the idea came from real-life garden clubs. The writers took that base and ran with it — adding scandal, suspense, and a few shady moves along the way.
You can stream Grosse Pointe Garden Society now on Apple TV+. If you’re up for laughs, love a good mystery, and enjoy a bit of attitude with your tea, this show’s worth your time.
Give it a shot. You might find yourself looking twice at your neighbor’s tulips after watching.
3. Based on a True Story
IMdb Rating: 7.8/10
In Based on a True Story , Melissa Fumero plays Marie — funny, quick-witted, and the kind of friend who tells it like it is. She’s not the main character, but when she shows up on screen, you notice her. She brings that charm she’s known for, and makes every moment count.
The story follows Ava and Nathan, a couple hooked on true crime podcasts. One day, they think they’ve found something real — a possible serial killer living next door. Instead of calling the cops, they get a wild idea: what if they start a podcast with him? Sounds nuts, right? It is. And things go from weird to worse fast.
This show mixes danger with humor in a way that’s hard to find. It’s spooky, it’s smart, and sometimes it’s flat-out hilarious. If you like true crime but don’t want to feel too heavy while watching, this one hits just right. Melissa’s role adds lightness without making light of the mess they’re in.
She fits right in with the chaos. Her jokes land. Her timing is sharp. And even though she’s not in every episode, when she’s there, you’re glad she is.
Here’s a little extra: Melissa got to walk the premiere red carpet with Terry Crews — her old Brooklyn Nine-Nine buddy. Fans loved seeing them back together. It was a fun moment, and a reminder of how much joy those two brought us before.
You can watch Based on a True Story on Peacock. If you’re after something thrilling, a bit twisted, and still full of laughs, this one’s worth your time.
Don’t sleep on it. Give it a try. You might just binge it faster than you expect.
4. Velma
IMdb Rating: 2.7/10
In Velma , Melissa Fumero uses her voice to bring life to Sophie — a smart, stylish high schooler in the spooky town of Crystal Cove. She’s not front and center, but when she speaks, you can tell Melissa is having fun with it. It’s cool to hear her in something so different from what she usually does.
This show gives the old Scooby-Doo crew a fresh look. But this time around, it’s all about Velma — before there was ever a gang. She’s trying to figure out what happened to her mom while also dealing with strange, creepy stuff happening at school. There’s mystery, sarcasm, teen drama, and more than a few surprises.
The style? Sharp. The jokes? Quick. The animation? Bold and unlike anything else out there.
If you like shows that mix mystery with humor and don’t mind something a little offbeat, Velma might just be your thing. It’s not for little kids — it’s made for older teens and adults who enjoy smart jokes and clever stories.
Some folks weren’t sure what to think when it first came out. Critics had mixed feelings. But a lot of people loved how bold it was. They liked how it took something familiar and turned it into something new.
Here’s a fun piece: Mindy Kaling voices Velma and helped shape the whole show. She and Melissa have worked together before — both known for being sharp, driven, and funny. You can feel that energy here too.
You can watch Velma on Max (used to be HBO Max). If you’ve got a taste for weird, wild stories and love a good mystery, check it out. And keep your ears open — Melissa’s voice is in there, adding a little extra flavor.
Give it a shot. You might just get hooked.
5. Night Court
IMdb Rating: 5.8/10
In Night Court , Melissa Fumero steps in as Olivia — a sharp, confident prosecutor who rolls into one episode like she owns the place. She’s not around for long, but when she’s on screen? You can’t take your eyes off her. She brings that signature charm, quick lines, and zero chill. It’s always a treat to see her pop up somewhere unexpected.
The show is a reboot of the classic ‘80s sitcom — same wild courtroom vibe, just updated. This time around, it’s Judge Abby Stone running the late-night show. She’s the daughter of the original judge, and she’s trying to bring a little fairness (and kindness) to the chaos of night court. The cases are weird. The people? Even weirder. But that’s what makes it so fun to watch.
It’s got that old-school sitcom feel — the kind that makes you laugh hard and still care about the people on screen. If you grew up watching the original, you’ll catch cool nods to the past. If you’re new to the whole thing, no worries — you’ll still enjoy the silly moments and characters who feel real, even when they’re acting totally nuts.
Melissa’s part may be short, but it’s packed with punch. And if you loved her in Brooklyn Nine-Nine , seeing her play another smart, driven character is just plain satisfying.
Here’s the kicker: she’s not the only familiar face. She worked alongside Stephanie Beatriz (her Brooklyn co-star) in another project not too long ago. So yeah, it’s kinda cool watching her keep popping up in all these fun places.
You can watch Night Court on Peacock. If you like your comedy fast, your characters quirky, and your courtroom full of oddballs, give it a shot. And don’t miss the episode with Melissa — she’s worth staying up for.
Trust me. Grab a snack, lean back, and hit play. You won’t regret it.
6. Digman!
IMdb Rating: 6.5/10
In Digman! , Melissa Fumero gives life to Bella — loud, bold, and full of fire. She’s not the main character, but when she shows up, you feel it. Her voice pops with energy, and you can tell Melissa’s having a blast in this wild, animated world.
The show takes place in a place where archaeologists are treated like stars. The main guy? Rip Digman — played by Andy Samberg (yep, Melissa’s old Brooklyn Nine-Nine buddy). He used to be big-time, now he’s trying to bounce back. So he dives headfirst into crazy adventures, chasing lost treasures, ancient secrets, and trouble — usually all at once.
It’s kind of like Indiana Jones if he had more jokes and less sense. The show mixes action with silly humor, fast lines, and that classic cartoon madness. It’s wild, it’s fun, and sometimes it’s just plain weird — in the best way possible.
If you like stories with adventure and laughs, Digman! hits the mark. It’s got heart, it’s got chaos, and it’s got Melissa and Andy working together again — even if just through voice. Fans of Brooklyn Nine-Nine will get a kick out of hearing them side by side once more.
Here’s a little extra: This was the first time Melissa and Andy shared a project since Brooklyn ended. That alone made fans smile. It felt like a reunion, just with more dinosaurs and exploding temples.
You can catch Digman! on Comedy Central or stream episodes online through Paramount+. If you’re into cartoons that mix action, humor, and a ton of personality, this one’s worth your time.
Don’t sleep on it. Check it out. You might just find yourself hooked on the madness.
7. Lopez vs. Lopez
IMdb Rating: 7.0/10
In Lopez vs. Lopez , Melissa Fumero shows up as Nayeli — a cool, fun character who brings some fresh energy to one of the episodes. She’s not around for long, but when she steps in, you feel it. Her charm? On full display. Her humor? Classic Melissa. Fans loved seeing her pop into this warm and funny show.
The story is about George Lopez — playing himself — and his daughter Mayan, played by his real-life daughter. They’ve had their share of bumps, so now they’re giving family life another shot. Living together again means clashing, laughing, arguing, and slowly learning how to really connect. It’s messy, it’s real, and it’s full of heart.
This show mixes laughs with something deeper. It’s not just jokes and awkward moments — though there are plenty of those — it’s also about what it means to be family, even when you don’t always see eye to eye. Melissa’s role fits right in. She adds a little spice, a few surprises, and makes that episode stand out.
She and George hadn’t worked together before, which made their pairing extra special. Two comedy stars from different worlds sharing the screen — fans noticed. And enjoyed.
If you like sitcoms that feel honest, that make you laugh and maybe even nod your head in recognition, Lopez vs. Lopez is worth your time.
You can catch it on NBC or stream it on Peacock. And if you do, don’t skip the episode with Melissa — it’s a good one. You’ll leave smiling.
8. Animaniacs
IMdb Rating: 8.0/10
In the wild and wacky world of Animaniacs , Melissa Fumero jumps in as a guest voice — not one of the main trio, but someone who brings her own flavor to the mix. She fits right into the chaos, sounding sharp and having fun with it. Fans were happy to hear her join the madness, especially knowing how much she loves animation.
The show stars Yakko, Wakko, and Dot — three crazy cartoon siblings who live in a water tower on the Warner Bros. lot. They bounce from one wild mess to another, singing silly songs, poking fun at history, and cracking jokes that fly over kids’ heads — straight to the grown-ups.
It’s not just cartoons and giggles. The reboot also brings back old favorites like Pinky and the Brain — two lab mice with big plans and zero luck. Every episode is packed with fast jokes, wild ideas, and music that sticks in your head.
Animaniacs is worth watching because it hits all the right notes for both kids and adults. It’s smart, it’s loud, and it knows exactly what it’s doing. Critics liked how it kept the old-school feel while giving it a fresh twist. And for fans of the original? It’s like catching up with old friends.
Melissa’s part may be small, but it’s full of life. And if you know how much she loves animated roles, this was basically made for her.
You can watch Animaniacs on Hulu. If you like your cartoons fast, funny, and full of heart — give it a try. Keep your ears open. You might just catch Melissa sneaking in with a punchline or two.
Trust me, it’s worth the ride.
9. Blockbuster
IMdb Rating: 5.1/10
In Blockbuster , Melissa Fumero plays Eliza — smart, strong, and full of that charm she’s known for. She’s one of the main workers at the last Blockbuster store in America. Eliza’s going through a rough breakup, trying to figure things out, and dealing with life one awkward moment at a time. Through it all, Melissa makes her real — funny, tough, and kind all at once.
The show is about a small group of workers holding on to something most people have left behind. DVDs? Rentals? Yeah, they’re still doing it. Their boss Timmy (played by Randall Park) loves the store like it’s family. He’s not ready to give up — even though everyone else is streaming now. Together, they try wild ideas to bring folks in. Some work. Some don’t. But it’s always fun watching them try.
It’s a workplace comedy with heart. It’s got laughs, yes — but also those quiet moments that make you think. If you ever stood in line with a movie in your hand, waiting to pop it in your VCR or DVD player, this show will feel familiar. It’s full of nostalgia, but not stuck in the past.
Critics weren’t all on the same page — some liked it, some didn’t. But fans loved the cast, the humor, and the warm feeling it gives. Melissa leading the pack? Just adds to the joy.
Here’s a cool detail: They built the show around a real-looking Blockbuster. The shelves, the posters, even the snacks — all there. You can almost smell the old carpet and popcorn just watching it.
You can catch Blockbuster on Netflix. If you like shows about coworkers who feel like family, throwback memories, and stories that make you laugh while tugging your heart, this one’s for you.
And hey, if you’ve missed seeing Melissa in a lead role — here she is. Shining again.
10. Diary of a Future President
IMdb Rating: 6.7/10
In Diary of a Future President , Melissa Fumero plays Gabi — a mom who’s full of love, grit, and quiet strength. She’s raising two kids on her own, and she does it with heart, humor, and hustle. You can feel how much she cares in every scene. Melissa makes Gabi real — not perfect, but always trying her best. And that bond she has with her on-screen kids? Feels totally true.
The show is about Elena, a 12-year-old Cuban-American girl just trying to get through middle school. But here’s the cool twist: we also see what her life looks like years later — as the President of the United States! So you get both sides — the everyday kid stuff and little hints of the leader she’ll become. It’s funny, smart, and sometimes hits hard in the feels.
It’s the kind of show that makes you smile while making you think. It’s about growing up, finding your voice, and knowing that even small moments can shape your future. The whole series is full of hope, culture, and strong family vibes. Critics loved how uplifting it was — and Melissa’s role as Gabi is a big part of why it all works.
Here’s a fun detail: Gina Rodriguez — who you might know from Jane the Virgin — not only produced the show, but she also plays the grown-up version of Elena. That connection gives the story extra soul.
You can watch Diary of a Future President on Disney+. If you want something that’s equal parts funny, warm, and inspiring — this one fits the bill.
And if you’ve ever had a mom who pushed you to be your best, or wish you had one like Gabi — this show will hit home. Melissa shines in it. Like she was born for this role.
Melissa Fumero has truly done it all — from solving crimes in Brooklyn Nine-Nine to voicing animated characters and playing heartfelt roles in family comedies. Whether she’s making us laugh, tearing up in emotional scenes, or bringing cartoons to life with her voice, Melissa always brings her best. These 10 TV shows show just how talented and versatile she really is.
Now it’s your turn! Have you watched any of these shows? Which Melissa Fumero role is your favorite? Did we miss a show you love? Drop your thoughts in the comments — we’d love to hear from you! Let’s celebrate this amazing actress together!
